Apr
22
Thoughts on American Idol | Top 6
Filed Under American Idol, Brooke White, Carly Hennessey Smithson, Carly Smithson, David Archuleta, David Cook, Jason Castro
I’m not going to write up a huge liveblog of tonight’s American Idol like I usually do. I will say that I enjoyed seeing Syesha Mercado on the AI stage tonight. She was looking pretty good and was singing well. However, overall Syesha faces overwhelming odds with the popularity of David Cook and David Archuleta this year.
Could Brooke White be going home tomorrow?
I like Brooke White — there’s something about her — be she won’t make it through to be the Idol this year. With her mistake, Brooke White will probably be thrown off the island.
I’ve never gotten into Jason Castro or Carly Smithson.
I can’t really get into Jason Castro — he seems like a nice guy — but that’s not enough to be the American Idol. And, I’ve never seen what others have seen in Carly Smithson — she has never made a connection with me. But, tonight’s performance will keep Carly Smithson safe for another week.
The real battle is between David Archuleta and David Cook.
The real battle for the number one position is between David Archuleta and David Cook in season 7 of American Idol.
The more I think about it, the more I think that David Cook will end up with the number one rank this year.
David Archuleta is good, but David Cook is older and is probably more marketable to a wider audience. But, don’t underestimate the power of David Archuleta’s many fans to dial and dial and dial for their favorite idol choice.
- Carly Smithson is going home tonight. I can't say that I am surprised to see Carly Smithson go home from...
- American Idol's Top 8 have had their chance to show their stuff to the American public. Who do you think...
- Here are Dial Idol's Predictions for the Top 7 on last night's American Idol. Safe: David Cook David Archuleta Jason...
- Michael Johns Michael Johns starts the night with Aerosmith's "Dream On." Randy says he is looking to see who...
- David Archuleta takes the first slot on tonight's American Idol competition featuring Mariah Carey's "When You Believe." Randy says David...
Comments
2 Responses to “Thoughts on American Idol | Top 6”
Leave a Reply
























An interesting process Chris. I have enjoyed the couple shows I’ve watched, but similar to the Barack Obama phenomenon, I just don’t see the celebrity appeal of watching it every week. But I know a lot of people do.
Hi Steve,
I’m going to have to find something new to write about because American Idol will soon be over and John Cook will be the winner