Carly Smithson sings Bonnie Tyler’s “Total Eclipse of the Heart.”

Carly’s got a big voice, but there’s something about her that makes me wonder if she can really be the American Idol.  Maybe it’s the big Amy Winehouse style arm tattoo that distracts me from her singing.

Randy:  “Very interesting song choice.  I didn’t love it.”  “I think it wasn’t the right song for you. … It was just okay.”

Paula:  “You could take every song that I’m not crazy about and make me buy it.”

Simon: “Something didn’t quite work.”  Simon didn’t enjoy Carly’s performance because she was too uptight.

Technorati Tags: American Idol, Bonnie Tyler, Carly Smithson, Total Eclipse of the Heart

Comments

• Twitter

• Akismet -- Spam Blocked

  17,974 spam comments

  blocked by
  Akismet

• Disclaimer

  
  
  Disclaimer: This site is not intended to provide legal advice or to establish an attorney-client relationship. Please seek legal assistance from an attorney. This site is intended for entertainment and education only. Please see full disclaimers in my "About" page.